The Buenos Aires Court of Criminal Appeal halved the sentence of an evangelical pastor for the rape of two girls aged 14 and 16 years, to understand that the victims were a social level to accept sex at a young age and because they had been with other men.
The ruling, issued by the room I, and was appealed to the Supreme Court of Buenos Aires by the Cassation prosecutor attached
Jorge Roldan, who said the decision "
discriminates against the most humble social sectors and therefore more vulnerable to certain crimes . "
The defendant, Francisco Avalos
59, Paraguay, had been sentenced by the Court Oral Moron 4 to 18 years in prison for sexually abused four aggravated sexual intercourse by a minister of religion, in perfect competition with two made to promote the corruption of a minor described by intimidation.
The incident occurred in April and August 2000 in the Evangelical Church Jesus is the Way
Park neighborhood of San Martín, in the locality of Merlo.
In its ruling, the maid
Horacio Piombo , whose voting joined Sal Llargués
Benjamin said that "
what was done by the accused, having sex with women who live in communities where the social relations agree very low ages (...) no I see it as morally uplifting, but not as a chore aberrant. "
argued that neither is "
repulsive, which harms the sexual integrity or which constitutes, as has been said, 'the pomp of dishonesty', marking-course," the concept of honesty with the current content variable. "
The maid was also considered to lower the penalties of 18 to 9 years and a half, that adolescents' sexual experience had
-even lie with men, and for which also operated the example set by other parties to convince natural sex in order to be able to conceive a child ".
to justify his vote, Piombo said he understands that "
all crimes that are built on social and cultural concepts, are impacted by the transformation of the meaning of language such entities suffer with over the years."
noted that the concept of honesty was not the same with the Criminal Code of 1921 that the renovated in 1999 and cited as an example that there are laws that totally changed, like marriage, which can now be between same sex.
The decision of the TOC 4 was revised by Moron Cassation after the pastor's defense appealed, at which time the prosecutor Carlos Altuve
had objected to an acquittal or sentence reductions. Altuve had remarked that the defendant took advantage of the "moral
enormous influence" that was on the victims, by cultural constraints, and after the first spread fear of the imminent end of the world, was presented as "
the embodiment of a spirit rescuer "With that excuse, saying that for girls only salvation was to be impregnated by him.
"This hoax
incredible individuals from other social origins, could Avalos 'enter' psychologically in the belief system of the victims, leaving them in a real 'trance state' where young people had no real alternatives to sexual submission intended her, "he said.
Instead, the defense minister had said that although there was possibly "
error" in the minors for the biblical virtues of Avalos, "
there was no error or defect the will of the same in terms of knowing that they were performing a sexual act, which was totally consensual . "
The lawyer also said that both would have had sexual experience and "
seeking" a child with the accused, which made the ground of violation.
After considering these arguments, the room I reduced the sentence for sexual abuse and directly pastor acquitted of the crime of corruption of a minor described by intimidation.
Source: Chronicle